Add own categories, delete default ones #1644

Hundhausen · 2019-11-09T11:28:56Z

Describe the solution you'd like
It would be nice if you could add own categories and delete default ones.

Additional context
With v2.0.0-beta2 and Issue #107 categories got added and so far it works. Categories from Thunderbird get shown in the web calendar and vice versa but it would be nice to delete unwanted default categories and add own categories for direct selection for the web calendar. I've looked into the files if there is an easy way to change this but as it looks, it isn't.

Want to back this issue? Post a bounty on it! We accept bounties via Bountysource.

Malspherus · 2020-01-30T07:28:17Z

You can add own categories in 2.0.1 (and probably also in some earlier versions). Deleting the defaults seems to not be possible at the moment, self-created categories don't show up in the list. Also see #71

Hundhausen · 2020-01-30T19:32:33Z

You miss understood me or I wasn't specific enough. Adding a own Category to one event works but also assigning this category to an other event needs to be done manually (I talk about the Web Interface). When multiply users have access to this Calendar, this would be an issue.

My idea is that an admin can add own categories that should be used as default and others not. When everyone needs to retype a category, small differences can occur and would mess things up.
You can color code every category to show how important something is. For example blue for a in house event, purple for external events, green for holidays, red for very important event and so on. It would be a mess if someone would messes up one category by slipping on the keyboard and adding a character and so messing up the color and people not noticing it.

For a single user, this won't be an issue, because in Thunderbird I can add my own categories and just using them but this isn't possible for the web client.

Malspherus · 2020-01-31T06:42:50Z

So in addition to what is available now:

Shareable list of categories for every calendar, prefilled with current defaults
Ability to add, remove and edit all categories in this list (which would probably mean updates to all events using them the way they are implemented at the moment)
Some kind of permission system. In your case not everyone who can add events should be able to add new categories but they should still be able to use existing ones
Sync of the whole list of categories to Thunderbird and other clients. I don't think that's possible right now, especially considering permissions

I could also imagine the Flow-App to integrate with this somehow, also kind of related to #1540 (Comment) for viewing categories easily I guess

Hundhausen · 2020-01-31T17:57:41Z

Sync/Download with other clients would be a nice to have but not really mandatory. I don't know if the Clients or the Protocol would support this. Also it's not so hard to add the Categories once in the clients.

Using the Permission System would be nice too but I don't know how hard it would be. I mean a calendar isn't something that strangers would have access to and I would expect that people would intentionally mess things up.

The core feature would be No. 1 and No. 2 just inside a Nextcloud for all Users.

A more complicated calendar for big company use would require a more in depth permission system and more automation. I think this would be too much to ask for.

MysticJay · 2020-03-23T10:52:24Z

I very much appreciate that calendar categories are now visible from the webinterface as well. But please refrain from syncing categories across clients. Esp when you share a calendar with others you do not want to see all their categories in your dropdown list nor would you like to use their colors.
In fact I share a calendar with colleagues and if an entry is assigned to a specific person we add that person's category. In the client (Thunderbird) I have only changed MY category to red the others are the same default color.
I have even removed all the default categories from TB as they can not be localized and you soon have "Privat", "private", "privé", as three categories instead of one.

But I recommend to
add all used categories to the list when a calendar gets imported
add new categories when used
but not re-add them when the user deleted a category manually.

M.

Gerhard386 · 2020-04-12T17:37:56Z

Hi,
we are a group of twenty people, who would like to use the nextcloud to organize our internal and external work. We are part of a larger organization, which provides the nextcloud for a lot of people with different interest/work.
But: We will have a restricted group and we need a calendar with our internal/external events.
Tor this the standard categories like "travelling" are not really useful. The typing and assigning of colours to them, will differenate even with probably 5 persons maintaining the calendar.
Therefore we would like to :

add fixed categories
add may later on more categories, when the need arise
remove the default
the group members should still have the possiblilty to "add" a new category, if it is more suitable for the purpose.
As a closed group, we do not care about the outerspace - neither other groups nor exchange with calendars in other systems/tools.
We would need no translation, just the text we enter at our defaults.
For the permission - I guess something like the "groupowner" - would be fine.
May be a first step would be an extension only for restricted/closed groups.
kind regards
Gerhard

amette · 2020-05-26T13:16:50Z

Not sure, if I understand @MysticJay correctly, but imho syncing categories across clients is absolutely necessary. I definitely want to have the same categories that I have in the web interface on my phone as well as in my desktop application.

Importing a shared calendar is probably a different thing. It would make sense to allow for 'do not import categories' or something similar.

georgehrke · 2020-05-26T13:18:13Z

, but imho syncing categories across clients is absolutely necessary.

Well, please start an initiative for an RFC, but right now there is no standard for it.

Treora · 2020-11-24T22:01:59Z

Here another user that would really appreciate creating a custom list of categories. As a workaround, I guess I could just change the default list in the source code of the instance? (I found a list in src/defaults/defaultCategories.js)

And regarding syncing the list of categories:

, but imho syncing categories across clients is absolutely necessary.

Well, please start an initiative for an RFC, but right now there is no standard for it.

Possibly of interest is RFC 7986 “New Properties for iCalendar”, which extends (see section 5.6) the CATEGORIES property to also be usable on the whole iCalendar object:

This specification modifies the definition of the "CATEGORIES"
property to allow it to be defined in an iCalendar object. The
following additions are made to the definition of this property,
originally specified in Section 3.8.1.2 of [RFC5545].

Purpose: This property defines the categories for an entire
calendar.

I have no idea if/which other software supports this, but it sounds like it may be suitable for this purpose. However one could also interpret the purpose as ‘listing the categories this calendar belongs to’, rather than ‘listing the categories its events can have’; I honestly do not know which meaning is intended.

mklemme1 · 2021-04-06T20:30:07Z

We have an events calendar of our club.
It is edited by multiple persons.
We want to use categories to publish meetings to different parts of our website.
Therefore configurable categories would be a real benefit.

Proposing again categories that were used before would already help.

mklemme1 · 2021-11-28T12:05:02Z

I have a similar request #3735.

WNYmathGuy · 2021-12-02T01:22:09Z

I'm a bit surprised this is open. I thought the Add a category to Calendar entries was implemented. Today I tried adding "Deadline" to one of my two NC instances and it did not work. Tried it via Ubuntu and Windows 11.

Gaming4LifeDE · 2022-02-12T13:26:32Z

Will this ever happen?

Nextcloud calendar in it's current state is completely unusable for a lot of people because the categories are a mess. Also I think the month view should show the color of the category but i guess that's a topic for a separate ticket.

Kayoku · 2022-11-29T09:54:26Z

Hi,

This feature is really really needed for use Nextcloud Calendar for a lot of people... Any news ?

vncntwbr · 2022-12-05T10:49:53Z

Would really love an update on this! Waiting 3 years for a simple modification to a dropdown menu does not seem appropriate...

ChristophWurst · 2022-12-05T15:14:11Z

@diabolicvincent-git you're probably right. Wanna give this a go? I can provide you with some pointers.

Kayoku · 2023-01-16T10:29:20Z

If you can provide some advice to help anyone who can add this on the plugin, it'll be really helpfull I think. In fact I would love to do it but I'm not really confortable with the language used here :D

…egories. This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used.

…egories. This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de>

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de>

fuco809 · 2023-06-05T09:17:00Z

are there configuration parameters for options like
*) disallow adding own categories (read only mode, use just existing/predefined ones)
*) disable default categories

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de> WIP

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Co-authored-by: Anna <anna@nextcloud.com> Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de>

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de> WIP

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de>

uchiit · 2024-02-26T19:27:14Z

Hi team!

Category visualization with colored tag in the year/month/week/day event view is a crucial feature, for example, to see past and future changes/features of events (remote or local event, event is completely closed or there is some documents left, etc.).

Will it be added in future releases?

petrarca-arezzo · 2024-03-19T13:56:23Z

One more voice here - being able to manage categories is crucial and a must (in my view) to be implemented (hopefully sooner than later)...

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used. Signed-off-by: Claus-Justus Heine <himself@claus-justus-heine.de>

This commit add all available "collaborative tags" and all already used categories into option groups of the tags-menu of the side-bar editor. Determining the set of already used categories is a little bit ugly: it used the oc_calendarobject_props table which might be considered "internal". However, this is the Nextcloud calendar app which only talks to the Nextcloud calendar server. So using this "internal ingredient" might be acceptable. This commit addresses and is a related to a couple of open issues: nextcloud#3735 Calendar Categories: Propose Categories already used - this should be fixed by this commit nextcloud#1644 Add own categories, delete default ones - this is partly fixed in the sense that collaboritive tags are now also proposed as calendar categories. - still default categories cannot be deleted - however, using option groups one at least has some sort of overview about the origin of the proposed category nextcloud/server#29950 Save VEVENT CATEGORIES as vcategory - this issue is totally "ignored" by this commit as the proposed solution there is not needed (the categories are already there in the oc_calendarobject_props table) - that would have to be discussed there: but my impression that the tables and classed mentioned there are obsolete and no longer used.

Hundhausen added 0. to triage Pending approval or rejection enhancement-proposed labels Nov 9, 2019

mklemme1 mentioned this issue Nov 28, 2021

Propose Categories already used #3735

Open

tcitworld removed the enhancement-proposed label Dec 17, 2021

rotdrop mentioned this issue Apr 24, 2023

Augment the category menu by system tags and already used categories #5161

Merged

ChristophWurst added 1. to develop Accepted and waiting to be taken care of enhancement New feature request labels Jun 1, 2023

ChristophWurst added 3. to review Waiting for reviews and removed 1. to develop Accepted and waiting to be taken care of labels Jun 28, 2023

ChristophWurst added 1. to develop Accepted and waiting to be taken care of and removed 3. to review Waiting for reviews labels Sep 28, 2023

joshtrichards changed the title ~~[Feature Request] Add own categories, delete default ones~~ Add own categories, delete default ones Aug 7, 2024

joshtrichards added the Feature: Categories label Aug 7, 2024

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Add own categories, delete default ones #1644

Add own categories, delete default ones #1644

Hundhausen commented Nov 9, 2019 •

edited by jospoortvliet

Loading

Malspherus commented Jan 30, 2020

Hundhausen commented Jan 30, 2020

Malspherus commented Jan 31, 2020

Hundhausen commented Jan 31, 2020

MysticJay commented Mar 23, 2020 •

edited

Loading

Gerhard386 commented Apr 12, 2020

amette commented May 26, 2020

georgehrke commented May 26, 2020

Treora commented Nov 24, 2020

mklemme1 commented Apr 6, 2021

mklemme1 commented Nov 28, 2021

WNYmathGuy commented Dec 2, 2021

Gaming4LifeDE commented Feb 12, 2022

Kayoku commented Nov 29, 2022

vncntwbr commented Dec 5, 2022

ChristophWurst commented Dec 5, 2022

Kayoku commented Jan 16, 2023

fuco809 commented Jun 5, 2023

uchiit commented Feb 26, 2024

petrarca-arezzo commented Mar 19, 2024

Add own categories, delete default ones #1644

Add own categories, delete default ones #1644

Comments

Hundhausen commented Nov 9, 2019 • edited by jospoortvliet Loading

Malspherus commented Jan 30, 2020

Hundhausen commented Jan 30, 2020

Malspherus commented Jan 31, 2020

Hundhausen commented Jan 31, 2020

MysticJay commented Mar 23, 2020 • edited Loading

Gerhard386 commented Apr 12, 2020

amette commented May 26, 2020

georgehrke commented May 26, 2020

Treora commented Nov 24, 2020

mklemme1 commented Apr 6, 2021

mklemme1 commented Nov 28, 2021

WNYmathGuy commented Dec 2, 2021

Gaming4LifeDE commented Feb 12, 2022

Kayoku commented Nov 29, 2022

vncntwbr commented Dec 5, 2022

ChristophWurst commented Dec 5, 2022

Kayoku commented Jan 16, 2023

fuco809 commented Jun 5, 2023

uchiit commented Feb 26, 2024

petrarca-arezzo commented Mar 19, 2024

Hundhausen commented Nov 9, 2019 •

edited by jospoortvliet

Loading

MysticJay commented Mar 23, 2020 •

edited

Loading