Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Is my camera working? An overview of tested cameras. #59

Open
24 of 25 tasks
cedricve opened this issue Dec 7, 2022 · 12 comments
Open
24 of 25 tasks

Is my camera working? An overview of tested cameras. #59

cedricve opened this issue Dec 7, 2022 · 12 comments
Assignees
Labels
enhancement New feature or request help wanted Extra attention is needed

Comments

@cedricve
Copy link
Member

cedricve commented Dec 7, 2022

New users, or existing community members, wonder if their old/new camera is expected to work with the Kerberos Agent. As reported on a previous issue kerberos-io/documentation#40, we want to provide a never-complete list of tested and approved cameras that work with the Kerberos Agent.

Call to action: If you have tested Kerberos Agent with your camera (with or without the sidecar for a USB camera), then feel free to add the camera name and model as a comment to this list. We will then update and maintain the approved camera list, so other community members can benefit from this, without buying or leveraging cameras that are not supported (or not yet supported).

USB cameras

  • Logitech BRIO 4K Stream Edition

IP Cameras

Amcrest

  • IP4M-1041

Avigilon

  • H3 H.264 (Zoom)
  • H4 H.264
  • H5A (Zoom)

Axis

  • P3245-LV
  • P3227-LV
  • M3066-V

Cantonk

CostarHD

  • RISE 4260HD Series (PTZ)
  • RISE 4261HD Series (PTZ)

Dahua

  • IPC-HFW2431S-S-S2

Eufy

  • Security Solo IndoorCam C24

Hanwha

  • RTSP support but ONVIF fails (investigating)

Hikvision

  • DS-2DE4415IW-DE (PTZ)
  • DS-2CD2043G2-I
  • DS-2CD2143G2-IS
  • DS-2CD2346G2-I Dome
  • DS-2CD6D54G1-IZ(S)

Reolink

  • E1 Pro (RTSP stream not stable, shows encoding issues) (Report)
  • TrackMix PoE (PTZ, Audio) (Only sub stream works). (Report)
  • E1 Outdoor (PTZ, Audio)

TP-link

  • Tapo C200 (PTZ, Audio) (Report)
  • Tapo C310

Wansview

  • W2
@cedricve cedricve added enhancement New feature or request help wanted Extra attention is needed labels Dec 7, 2022
@cedricve cedricve pinned this issue Dec 7, 2022
@cedricve cedricve self-assigned this Dec 7, 2022
@cedricve
Copy link
Member Author

cedricve commented Dec 26, 2022

added CostarHD + sorted the list

@olokos
Copy link
Contributor

olokos commented Jan 15, 2023

I can confirm that the Raspberry Pi HQ Camera / IMX477R works with the new Agent approach to cameras.

If You want to use non-default resolution then mode has to be set according to the mode used by the camera.

The only issue I see with the new approach is:
image
(Censored local IP for privacy)

Which was mentioned here as solved
bluenviron/mediamtx#1133

But it still happens, with that said both Agent and VLC display the stream as they should, despite the error!
I cannot see any issues with the stream or any performance downgrades, all seem to run great, including some of the camera parameters that I used!

EDIT: Now that I saw the image there's a lot of artifacts and the stream is quite unstable on its own, VLC doesnt always connect. I'll post an update later.

Edit2: The problem with artifacts is because of 846kb bitrate vs 10mbps bitrate which was set automatically before

@milankragujevic
Copy link
Contributor

Cantonk IPR25FE500 - https://www.cantonk.com/product/detail/594.html

Confirmed working as basic rtsp:// stream.

@nudzik
Copy link

nudzik commented Feb 5, 2023

Tp-link Tapo C310 and eufy security Solo IndoorCam C24 are working very well.

@Hooch76
Copy link

Hooch76 commented Mar 13, 2023

Wansview W2 works fine.

@cedricve
Copy link
Member Author

cedricve commented May 7, 2023

Tried out a Reolink E1 PRO, but doesn't work as expected the RTSP stream delivered (you have 2, fluent and clear) shows artifacts. It's also not reliable, even with VLC it doesn't open continuously.

I was able to connect a Kerberos Agent to the stream but most of the time it was showing encoding issues, at some points it was properly recording, but disconnected after a while.

Screenshot 2023-05-07 at 20 27 54

@cedricve
Copy link
Member Author

cedricve commented May 9, 2023

Tested, Tapo C200 works well! Audio (PCM_ALAW) and ONVIF PTZ is working. Please note that ONVIF PTZ is running on port 2020

Main stream

rtsp://xxx:xxx@192.168.1.xxx:554/stream1

Secondary stream

rtsp://xxx:xxx@192.168.1.xxx:554/stream2

@cedricve
Copy link
Member Author

cedricve commented Jun 1, 2023

We have verified the Reolink TrackMix PoE, as expected it gives some inconsistent behaviour. The camera comes with the two channels, for which the first channel is a wide-angle.

  • The wide angle main stream doesn't work as it's a H265 stream.

    rtsp://xxx:xxx@192.168.1xxx:554/h264Preview_01_main

  • The wide angle secondary stream does work as it's a H264 stream.

    rtsp://xxx:xxx@192.168.1xxx:554/h264Preview_01_sub

In contrast to the Reolink E1 pro, this camera does give a stable secondary stream both for live streaming (WEBRTC) as recording.

We have validated the PTZ functionality, and the PTZ works properly. Please note that you'll need to enable both the RTSP and ONVIF functionality in the Reolink admin panel before you can open the stream or leverage ONVIF functions.

@cedricve
Copy link
Member Author

cedricve commented Nov 6, 2023

We tested Hanwha cameras, and RTSP seams to be working fine after fixing #105. ONVIF is not yet working, figuring out the root cause. Special thanks to @0xhanh

@marcosr25
Copy link

One question, have you connected your cameras locally? I want to connect them externally through the public IP of the router (modem). I have already opened ports 2020 and 554 with port forwarding to 8120, 8121=2020 and 554=554 with for my tp-link tapo c310 and c320ws cameras, now I have configured the accounts of both cameras for the Onvif protocol. From the panel I add the configuration and it tells me that ONVIF settings are successfully verified. and when you click save Your configuration has been updated successfully. but I can't view them. Isn't it possible this way? thanks greetings

@RickAndTired
Copy link

Amcrest IP4M-1041
RTSP works well
ONVIF does not work for me (could be a user issue)

@cedricve
Copy link
Member Author

cedricve commented Jul 7, 2024

Thank you for reporting @RickAndTired

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
enhancement New feature or request help wanted Extra attention is needed
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

7 participants